Tagged: fiction

Knots and Crosses

knots and crossesKnots and Crosses: An Inspector Rebus Novel by Ian Rankin, 2/5

This has about the same depth, complexity and uniqueness as the plot of an average episode of any old crime TV show.  The story unfolds in a way that leaves the reader as clueless throughout as the main character seems to be and the ending feels rushed, with no real payoff.  The most interesting part of the book was multiple appearances of the unusual word “outwith,” which is Scottish for “outside” or “beyond.”

[Why I read it: I enjoyed the first season of Rebus (a TV show based on Rankin’s literary character) but the show did a complete cast reboot for the second season and I didn’t like the new actors (or the new writers and director, for that matter) at all.  While reading reviews, looking for some commiseration, I was surprised that several people liked the new series because they felt it was truer to the books’ portrayal of the character.  Realising I was one of those annoying people who have an opinion on the movie but have never even read the book, I hastened to remedy the situation and was punished for my sins with the first novel, which so failed to inspire me to read any more books in the series that I can’t even imagine how it inspired a TV show.]

Forever Rumpole

forever rumpoleForever Rumpole: The Best of the Rumpole Stories by John Mortimer, 3/5

Rumpole, an irreverent, outspoken and devastatingly sarcastic barrister, specialising in criminal law, is the scourge of judges but the delight of juries (who he entertains) and the criminal classes (who he generally gets acquitted).  The character is appealing, but I felt that the stories were lacking in complexity and substance.  Also, it’s challenging to respect a character who is portrayed as having the reputation, amongst criminals, of a guaranteed procurer of “not guilty” verdicts.  I’d rather read a story about the defence of an innocent, decent person than the defence of someone who’s only a petty thief and con-man and thus would never have committed the murder in question…

[Why I read it: I’ve been meaning to watch the TV show but just got around to the book first, thinking it sounded like fun.]